Show Related Links +

Is Food As We Know It Doomed?

Contributor: By Amy Klimek, MA, LCPC, Director of Program Development, Eating Disorder Program Coordinator, Timberline Knolls Residential Treatment Center

green-422995_640The food pendulum is always in motion, swinging back and forth from good to bad. One day eggs are a super food; the next, they are viewed as cholesterol killers. One month, whole grain is the only way to go; the following month’s message is to avoid all things with gluten.

Meal replacement is precisely that–it reduces food to handy bags of non-appetizing particles that are mixed with water. The idea of it taps into a person’s desire to provide their body with good solid nutrition in the shortest amount of time possible.

Ambronite and Soylent are the two most common brands in the industry today. The former appears most concerned with health, while the latter is particularly focused on time-saving. Both products are promoted as ready-to-go meals for breakfast, lunch and dinner.

The Problem with Meal Replacements

At first blush, these products have a certain appeal, appearing to be nutritionally sound. And through the website’s display of attractive visuals of grains and vegetables and the claim that each drink contains dozens of important vitamins and minerals, that notion is reinforced. But the problem remains–the meal is liquid.

The human body is designed to deal with solid food. A person chews food, swallows, then all the digestive juices from the mouth and stomach go about their work of breaking the food down—a process that has endured for millions of years.

Enter days, weeks or months of simply drinking liquid. This is contrary to how the body was created to function. It is no wonder that extreme diarrhea or constipation can result. And it does beg the question: are all these great vitamins and minerals actually being absorbed into the system, or simply flushing out with the rest of the liquid?

The Expense of Replacing Regular Food

tablet-428328_640What’s more, these products are not inexpensive, with a bag containing ten meals priced at approximately $80. Keep in mind, three to five “meals” are suggested each day.
Even if a person “could” drink all their meals, accept the consequences and afford the cost, why would they?

Think of the visual loss of the beautiful colors of fruits and vegetables or the exquisite intricacies of special desserts. Consider the loss of savory flavors and textures–all of which cannot be replicated in a bag.

Losing More than the Taste of Food

Perhaps most of all, think of the vast social loss. Like it or not, much of our socializing is conducted around food—a lunch date with a friend, a coffee break with a colleague, a quiet dinner with a loved one. All would be sacrificed. And to what end: saving time?

These products are billed as a method to simplify life. If someone is too busy to eat a meal three times a day, 7 days a week, then that person is just too busy. Their life is out of balance, probably not sustainable. They will need a lot more to fix it than food in a bottle.

Community Discussion – Share your thoughts here!

What are your thoughts on the benefits of whole food nutrition?

The opinions and views of our guest contributors are shared to provide a broad perspective of eating disorders. These are not necessarily the views of Eating Disorder Hope, but an effort to offer discussion of various issues by different concerned individuals.

Last Updated & Reviewed By: Jacquelyn Ekern, MS, LPC on December 18th, 2014
Published on

Share our content:Share on FacebookTweet about this on TwitterShare on Google+Share on LinkedInPin on PinterestShare on RedditEmail this to someone

{ 3 comments… read them below or add one }

Vanessa P. January 7, 2015 at 8:53 am

This article was exactly what I needed to read in the face of all the new fad diets & such that seem to be EVERYWHERE right now with all these resolutions people made. Even my office has a thing going on right now where members of my team are competing (with a monetary penalty if you drop out or gain weight in your weekly weigh in) & spreading their “secrets” around – one of them being liquid diets. Even with 21 months free of acting on ED behaviors, it can be overwhelming at times. This was a great reminder that my meal plan is what’s best, it’s what is proven & meant to work, & my body deserves the downtime I give it when I eat.

I have the honor of knowing Amy personally as my Eating Disorder Specialist during my time at TK & she’s someone I greatly respect to this day. She’s someone who incorporates what she teaches into her own life & because of that I really look up to her. I swear I could hear her voice in the last part of this article as she stated: “These products are billed as a method to simplify life. If someone is too busy to eat a meal three times a day, 7 days a week, then that person is just too busy. Their life is out of balance, probably not sustainable. They will need a lot more to fix it than food in a bottle.”

Perfect topic to kick off 2015…thanks guys!

Crystal Karges MS, RDN, IBCLC January 8, 2015 at 12:02 pm

Thank you so much for your feedback Vanessa! We appreciate hearing from you and wish you a wonderful 2015!

Danielle payne January 30, 2015 at 7:55 pm

This is fabulous!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Leave a Comment

Search Eating Disorder Hope